Are the Covenanters a Cult?
The Exclusive Claim to Being
the Most Faithful Church:
An Inescapable Concept
by Michael Wagner, PhD
"This collection of 62 CDs is a truly
astounding accomplishment. There is nothing like this available to the ordinary
Christian on the whole face of the earth. Now, for the first time ever, ordinary
Christians can have direct and near effortless access to the very cream
of Puritan and Reformed, as well as Covenanter, literature... What they used
to say of the Puritan John Flavel's preaching, can be said of these CDs: they
are 'hissing hot'! ... more" (emphases added).
- Dr Jonathan D. Moore, Cambridge, UK.
(Scholar of
16th and 17th century Calvinistic literature.)
See Reformation Bookshelf CD 27 for
books on Covenant theology and covenanting.
Links to
all 90 SWRB CDs related to our new 3 for 1 CD SUPER SALE (LIMITED TIME
OFFER) .
SWRB Has Been Serving
Christians worldwide (in over 100 countries) for 24+ years.
*** IMPORTANT COVENANTER NOTICE
***
HOW TO GET 60 FREE SWRB CDs (UNTIL THE END OF THE DAY October 13,
2008) BY THE BEST CLASSIC AND CONTEMPORARY PURITANS, REFORMERS, COVENANTERS,
CALVINISTS, PRESBYTERIANS, REFORMED BAPTISTS, PROTESTANTS, et al. (CLICK
ON THE LINK BELOW)
http://www.swrb.com/Puritan/60_FREE_PURITAN_CDs.htm
See Reformation Bookshelf CD 27 for
books on Covenant theology and covenanting.
Select Customer Comments on
SWRB's Reformation Bookshelf CD set.
"Still Waters Revival Books... have
released an incredible array of... compact disks which contain over 2,000
titles of some of the best Reformation and Calvinistic books ever written.
It is by far the best and widest collection of Reformed literature ever
assembled...
more"
- The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined,
Defended, and Documented, Second (Special 40th Anniversary) Edition, Updated and
Expanded (p. 76, 2004, Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Company) by David
N. Steele, Curtis C. Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn, Foreword by Roger Nicole,
Afterword by John MacArthur (emphases added).
______________
"I have been systematically working through
reading the... Reformed CDs I purchased. I must say, there is nothing like
them available anywhere. It is the most amazing collection of works I know of
in one package to date... The Puritan and Reformed material presented on these CDs
is exceptional. I am continually amazed at the depth and breadth of information
in both collections, and the rarity of works that I now have at my fingertips.
You have done an immeasurable service for the Kingdom of Christ in making these
CDs available, and every pastor and theologian should own them without question
(they would be foolhardy to pass them by) ... more"
- For Christ's Crown and Covenant,
Dr. C.
Matthew McMahon, A Puritan's Mind Ministries
______________
"Your... CD's of Reformation and Puritan
authors are a great boon to studies in the Reformed-Puritan experiential
tradition. Receive our hearty thanks for your invaluable work in making so many
rare gems accessible to thousands."
- Dr. Joel R. Beeke, President of Puritan
Reformed Theological Seminary
______________
Many more comments on the Reformation
Bookshelf CD set of 30 CDs (by the Banner of Truth magazine, Calvin Beisner
[Professor of Historical Theology and Social Ethics at Knox Theological
Seminary], Dr. E.P. Elliott [Christian Observer magazine], and many
others.)
can be found at the end of the page at: http://www.swrb.com/Puritan/reformation-bookshelf-CDs.htm
*** Get 60
CLASSIC SWRB (PURITAN, REFORMATION, COVENANTER, CALVINISM, etc.) CDs for FREE!
***
60 NEW SWRB CDs, 3 for 1 CD SUPER SALE with
ADDITIONAL PREPUBLICATION DISCOUNTS (for a limited time only)!
"Your...
CD's of Reformation and Puritan authors are a great boon to studies in the
Reformed-Puritan experiential tradition. Receive our hearty thanks for your
invaluable work in making so many rare gems accessible to thousands."
- Dr. Joel R. Beeke, President of Puritan
Reformed Theological Seminary
"Still
Waters Revival Books... have released an incredible array of... compact disks
which contain over 2,000 titles of some of the best Reformation and Calvinistic
books ever written. It is by far the best and widest collection of Reformed
literature ever assembled"
(The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented, Second [Special 40th Anniversary]
Edition, Updated and Expanded [p. 76, 2004, Presbyterian and Reformed
Publishing Company] by David N. Steele, Curtis C. Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn,
Foreword by Roger Nicole, Afterword by John MacArthur, emphases added).
"I
have been systematically working through reading the Puritan and Reformed CDs I
purchased... I must say, there is nothing like them available anywhere. It is
the most amazing collection of works I know of in one package to date... You
have done an immeasurable service for the Kingdom of Christ in making these CDs
available, and every pastor and theologian should own them without question
(they would be foolhardy to pass them by)" (Dr. C. Matthew McMahon, A Puritan's Mind Ministries).
The
most extensive classic Christian CD library ever (on 90 CDs)!
(The best
of the Puritans, Covenanters, Reformers, Baptists, Presbyterians, et al.)
90 Christian CDs In
Total, Containing The Best Of Classic and Contemporary Christian Books (PDFs),
MP3s, and Videos on Puritanism, the Reformation, the Covenanters (Like
Gillespie, Rutherford, Durham, Manton, Cameron, Renwick, Love, et al.), the
Westminster Divines (Like Gouge, Twisse, Henderson, Caryl, Burgess, et al.),
the Puritans (Like Watson, Owen, Flavel, Sibbes, Brooks, Charnock, Edwards, et
al.), Baptists (Like Spurgeon, Pink, Bunyan, et al.), Presbyterians (Like
Calvin, Knox, Triall, Boston, Miller, Dabney, Thornwell, et al.), Calvinism and
the Calvinists (Like Hodge, Henry, the Erskines, Shedd, et al.), the Reformers
(Like Wycliffe, Tyndale, Luther, Bullinger, Foxe, Bradford, Beza, Perkins, et
al.), the 1599 Geneva Bible (retypeset and searchable), Classic Puritan and
Reformation Commentaries, and Much, Much More!
LIMITED TIME ONCE-IN-A-LIFETIME
PREPUBLICATION OPPORTUNITY FOR HUGE SAVINGS (UP TO AN ADDITIONAL $200 OFF OUR 3
FOR 1 DISCOUNT OFFER!)
ADDITIONAL PREPUBLICATION DISCOUNTS ONLY
GUARANTEED UNTIL THE END OF THE DAY October 13, 2008 -- so if
you have any questions or would like to place an order please call us at
1-780-450-3730 (24 hours a day, leave a message if you get voice mail and we
will return your call), email us at swrb@swrb.com,
Fax 780-468-1096, or use our secure order form at https://www.shopalberta.com/SWRB/.
"This
collection of... CDs is a truly astounding accomplishment. There is nothing
like this available to the ordinary Christian on the whole face of the earth.
Now, for the first time ever, ordinary Christians can have direct and near
effortless access to the very cream of Puritan and Reformed, as well as
Covenanter, literature... What they used to say of the Puritan
John Flavel's preaching, can be said of these CDs: they are 'hissing hot'! (Dr Jonathan D. Moore, Cambridge, Scholar
of 16th and 17th century Calvinistic literature.).
Click on
the links below for the contents of all 90 Classic SWRB CDs offered in our new
3 for 1 CD SUPER SALE, including money saving details on additional discounts
through our time limited PREPUBLICATION OFFER -- save up to $200 more by purchasing these CDs before October 13, 2008 .
CLICK
ON THE LINKS BELOW FOR FULL DETAILS ON HOW TO GET 60 SWRB CDs FOR FREE
ADDITIONAL PREPUBLICATION DISCOUNTS ONLY
GUARANTEED UNTIL THE END OF THE DAY October 13, 2008 -- so if
you have any questions or would like to place an order please call us at
1-780-450-3730 (24 hours a day, leave a message if you get voice mail and we
will return your call), email us at swrb@swrb.com,
Fax 780-468-1096, or use our secure order form at https://www.shopalberta.com/SWRB/.
"Your...
CD's of Reformation and Puritan authors are a great boon to studies in the
Reformed-Puritan experiential tradition. Receive our hearty thanks for your
invaluable work in making so many rare gems accessible to thousands." (Joel Beeke, President of Puritan
Reformed Theological Seminary).
Secure Online Order
Form (Click Here Now!)
OTHER
SWRB CONTACT INFORMATION
swrb@swrb.com
Phone
780-450-3730 (Please call if you have any questions.)
Fax
780-468-1096
4710-37A
Ave., Edmonton, AB, Canada, T6L 3T5
"These
Puritan resources are the greatest I've ever seen. These eyes have never seen
anything greater than what you have produced except that old King James
Bible" (Email from a
Customer in Georgia, USA).
Some
Additional Customer Comments on SWRB's CD sets (Reformation, Calvinism,
Protestant, Puritan).
"This collection
of… CDs is a truly astounding accomplishment. There is nothing like this
available to the ordinary Christian on the whole face of the earth. Now, for the first
time ever, ordinary Christians can have direct and near effortless access to the
very cream of Puritan and Reformed, as well as Covenanter, literature... What they used
to say of the Puritan John Flavel's preaching, can be said of these CDs: they
are 'hissing hot'! ... more" (emphases added).
- Dr Jonathan D. Moore,
Cambridge, UK.
(Scholar of
16th and 17th century Calvinistic literature.)
"The
purchase of (SWRB's) CD's is proving to be one of the wisest investments that I
have ever made.
They are much more than I expected!! I am having a wonderful time reading and
studying."
-
TC, Internet Customer (USA).
"The
greatest collection of classic Reformation resources on one CD set ever!"
"In
reading this mornings mailing I noticed that you also do the Reformation
Bookshelf CD's so I went to your web site to see what was out -- I was in
ecstasy!!!"
-
Missionary working in Hatyai, Southern Thailand
Full
SWRB CD comment from Dr. McMahon:
"I
have been systematically working through reading the Puritan and Reformed CDs I
purchased.
I must say, there is nothing like them
available anywhere.
It is the most amazing collection of works I
know of in one package to date.
In
my opinion, it far surpasses Ages Software and their collections.*
The
Puritan and Reformed material presented on these CDs is exceptional.
I
am continually amazed at the depth and breadth of information in both
collections, and the rarity of works that I now have at my fingertips.
You
have done an immeasurable service for the Kingdom of Christ in making these CDs
available, and every pastor and theologian should own them without question
(they would be foolhardy to pass them by)."
-
For Christ's Crown and Covenant,
Dr. C.
Matthew McMahon
A Puritan's
Mind Ministries, www.apuritansmind.com
John 5:39,
"...search the Scriptures..."
"Novum
Testamentum in Vetre latet, et in Novo, Vetus patet." Augustine
( "The
New is in the Old concealed, and in the New, the Old revealed." )
* It is SWRB's
opinion that Ages has done an excellent job in making various Reformed works
available on CD, so much so that we also distribute a number of their CDs at
discounts. Thus, please don't make more out of our publishing this comment than
is warranted, as this is a comment we received from one of our customers and it
expresses his opinion. As for Ages' work, we rejoice whenever the truth is
published, whether through others or through SWRB (as we play only a very small
part in the revival of classic Reformation, Puritan and Covenanter thought that
is now taking place worldwide through God's marvelous grace). The publication
of the best Reformers and Puritans of the past is one of the greatest needs of
our time, as this extends the blessings that come through faithful preachers
and authors into our day and into the future. Lord willing, the growth in the
publishing of faithful works from the past will help stem the tide of the great
declension and unfaithfulness which we are now witnessing all around us, even
(sadly) among many churches that still call themselves "Presbyterian"
and/or "Reformed." So please pray together with us that our Lord will
multiple the number of faithful publishers and publications, and that He will
give many the heart to stand for the truth no matter the consequences (as He
has done for our faithful forefathers, who resisted Satan and sin unto blood
and even to martyrdom in many cases). -- RB.
"SWRB's
Puritan and Reformation CD libraries are an invaluable source for the study of
the history and theology of classic Reformation theology. The collection is
remarkable not only for depth of content, but also for the rarity of many of
the works. Most seminary libraries will not have even a percentage of the works
available on these CD-ROMs. I cannot imagine anyone working in Reformation /
historical theology that would not want to use the Puritan and Reformed
libraries!"
-
Phillip J. Long
Associate
Prof. of New Testament
Grace Bible
College
Grand
Rapids, MI 49509
"I
just received your CD collection. One bit of advice: you should instruct your
customers to take about 1 week off just to peruse the tables of contents for
these CD's, followed by another week off, in order to recover from the
state of shock in which they will find themselves.
In
all seriousness, this collection is almost impossible to describe. It has to be
seen to be believed. As a pastor, my library has just increased
dramatically.
As a Ph.D. student in Puritan and Post-Reformation studies, I have immediate
access to many of the same works for which I would normally need to access
through rare book rooms of theological libraries.
Thank
you for this labor of love. Thank you for making it accessible, both
financially and technologically. May the Lord richly bless you for this service
to his people."
-
Yours for the faith,
Pastor David Owen Filson
Good Shepherd Presbyterian Church (PCA), Nashville, TN
"You
all are doing a wonderful service by making all these materials so readily
available. Having them on my hard drive is BETTER than having access to a
rare book library with all of them in hand... I have found the CD set
invaluable as a tool of scholarship. So once again I commend you brothers for making
it available."
-
Dr. E. Calvin Beisner
Knox
Theological Seminary
Author and
Associate Professor of Historical Theology and Social Ethics
(Author of: Psalms
of Promise: Celebrating
the Majesty and Faithfulness of God, God in Three Persons, Answers: For Atheists, Agnostics,
and Other Thoughtful Skeptics--Dialogs About Christian Faith and Life, Man,
Economy, and Environment in Biblical Perspective, Where Garden Meets Wilderness:
Evangelical Entry Into the Environmental Debate, Evangelical Heathenism? Examining Contemporary Revivalism, as well as other books, scholarly
papers, and contributions to various anthologies).
"It's
been several weeks now since I received the CDs and have had some time to
digest some of them. All I can say is, "WOW!" This is truly a
library like no other, and has already paid great dividends not only in my own
personal worship and study, but in my teaching as well. I first balked at the
price, but after seeing the vastness of the material, I almost feel as though
I'm robbing you!
I
pray that the Lord will allow you to get these materials into the hands of as
many ministers as possible."
-
Email from SC, USA
Full
SWRB CD comment from Dr. Moore:
This
collection of 62 CDs is a truly astounding accomplishment. There is nothing
like this available to the ordinary Christian on the whole face of the earth.
Now,
for the first time ever, ordinary Christians can have direct and near
effortless access to the very cream of Puritan and Reformed, as well as
Covenanter, literature.
These
books are often in fascinating first editions and many are electronically
linked and indexed for the first time. The ordinary Christian may here dig
into a simply staggering wealth of literature, from devotional and sermonic
material to technical and scholarly works. Even in the days of the Long Reformation
itself ordinary Christians didn't get to see this kind of library -- most
couldn't read for a start, and even those who could, would never have been able
to afford to buy even a hundredth part of the material on these CDs. Truly we
are without excuse!
And
the significance of this collection goes even beyond that. No longer do we have
to wait for modern Reformed publishing houses to predict that a particular
Reformation or Puritan book will be sufficiently popular to make it economical
to reprint, or to deem it "safe" enough to be let loose on the modern
evangelical church. Rather, we are now able to see for ourselves the whole
range of the Puritan and Reformed publishing enterprise, including views that
are usually suppressed by most modern devotees of "Puritan" piety!
Buy
these CDs while you can, and find out for yourself what the First and Second
Reformations were really all about! You'll be truly amazed, and, by God's
grace, will grow from being an ordinary Christian to being an extraordinary
one. What they used to say of the Puritan John Flavel's preaching, can be
said of these CDs: they are "hissing hot"!
-
Dr Jonathan D. Moore, Cambridge, UK.
(Scholar of
16th and 17th century Calvinistic literature.)
"This
side of eternity I'll never be able to repay the favor you have done mankind by
bringing these... CDs together.
The
first week of reading I grew more as a Christian reading those rich, pure
Gospel Commentators than I have in 18 years of Christian life. After reading some of
the Puritan CDs I have to get the Reformation set if it kills me. A fire is
burning within me. These... CDs are liable to start a revival fire unseen in
any generation... the Gospel in its pure form is seen in these... CDs.
Sir,
I cant say enough. What a treasure! I'll never be able to repay you this side of
heaven, but when we get there I am sure you will see the rich fruits of your
labor. God bless you for not being money hungry but wanting to see Christians
grow in the Lord... I love you even though we have never met, you have
helped me in my Christian walk tremendously with these... CDs.
I
am not bragging on the flesh, I am just giving honor where honor is due. The
Holy Ghost will take these CDs and light a fire unseen and unheard of. God
bless you all at Still Waters."
-
Email from the USA
"Thank
you so very much for the CDs.
I am amazed at the quality and quantity of
the literature...
I
cannot imagine any other single thing being done by any man or group of men in
the earth today that is of such extensive, present, and enduring value as
this CD work is.
God
be praised that he uses sickly and weak men to forward his kingdom, that the
work may not be mistaken to be wrought by the might of men, but by his Spirit.
His strength is perfected in weakness."
-
Email from Colorado
______________
Many more comments on the SWRB's CD sets
(by the Banner of Truth magazine, Calvin Beisner [Professor of
Historical Theology and Social Ethics at Knox Theological Seminary], Dr. E.P.
Elliott [Christian Observer magazine], and many others.) can be found at the
end of the page at: http://www.swrb.com/Puritan/calvinism-bookshelf-CDs.htm
HOW TO GET 60 FREE SWRB CDs (UNTIL THE END OF THE DAY October 13,
2008) BY THE BEST CLASSIC AND CONTEMPORARY PURITANS, REFORMERS, COVENANTERS,
CALVINISTS, PRESBYTERIANS, REFORMED BAPTISTS, PROTESTANTS, et al. (CLICK
ON THE LINK BELOW)
http://www.swrb.com/Puritan/60_FREE_PURITAN_CDs.htm
Still
Waters Revival Books (www.swrb.com)
Free and Discount Covenanter, Puritan and Reformed
Christian book distributors serving Christians worldwide (in over 100
countries) for 24+ years.
[Reformation Bookshelf
CDs][Bibles][Books][Music-Psalters-CDs][Sermons & Books on Cassette][Rare Bound Photocopies][Videos][Newsletters][Reformed Children's Books][Super Sales][Free Puritan Books and MP3s]
For SECURE
ONLINE ORDERING (click here)
CLICK HERE TO SEARCH SWRB's COMPLETE SITE
Postage
and handling chart, how to order, etc.
CONTACT Still Waters Revival Books:
Email swrb@swrb.com, Phone 780-450-3730, FAX
780-468-1096, Mail 4710-37A Ave. Edmonton, Alberta, Canada T6L 3T5
Add yourself to our SUPER SPECIAL email list by sending an email
to add@swrb.com -- for email notices of our best
time-limited sales, new releases, and new FREEBIES (i.e. new FREE etext and new
FREE MP3 audio sermons and classic Reformed books read on tape). Your email
address will be kept private (as we do not sell or trade email addresses in any
way) and you may remove yourself from the list at any time -- as easy (one
email) remove instructions come with every email. This is also a double
opt-in email list, so we
will email you to confirm your email address and to confirm that you want to
join our list. A small selection of previous email sales may be viewed at EMAIL SUPER SPECIALS (http://www.swrb.com/puritan-books.htm). Thank you for visiting our site and we
hope that you find it to be a great blessing!
THE FIVE POINTS of this
EMAIL SUPER SALE
1. "Are the Covenanters a Cult?" by Michael Wagner, PhD
2. Resources related to "Are the Covenanters a
Cult?"
Resources
#2, #4, #7, #10, #14 and #15 are all first time email sale listings!
3. *All EMAIL SUPER SALES,
FREE TAPE & DOUBLE FREE TAPE offers expire October 13, 2008* http://www.swrb.com/puritan-books.htm
4. One FREE cassette (of less that $US4 value, see list at: http://www.swrb.com/music/cassets.htm )
for every $US10 ordered before October 13, 2008 --
with even more discounts due to the great exchange rate on the weak Canadian
dollar!
5. DOUBLE FREE TAPES (i.e. TWO FREE TAPES [of less than $US4 value] for every $US10.00 purchased)
on 15 select SUPER SALE RESOURCES only (if purchased
before October 13, 2008). SEE: http://www.swrb.com/Puritan/Double-Free-Tapes-Sale.htm
Are the Covenanters a Cult?
The Exclusive Claim to Being
the Most Faithful Church:
An Inescapable Concept
by Michael Wagner, PhD
The Puritan
Reformed Church (PRC) claims that it is the most faithful church currently in
existence of which it is aware. This claim is based on the fact that it
is the only contemporary church which adheres to all of the doctrinal and
practical attainments of the Second Reformation, namely the complete
package of the Westminster Standards as adopted by the Church of Scotland
(Confession, Catechisms, Directories, Covenants, etc., see http://prce.cjb.net/ ). This claim has
sparked sharp criticism, even the false and ungodly allegation that the PRC has
become a "cult." In effect, this astounding libel would make the
majority of the Westminster Divines, not to mention many other major Reformers,
cultists themselves! In the view of the critics, all conservative Reformed and
Presbyterian churches are, more or less, faithful churches. Thus for one church
to call itself the "most faithful" is a mark of arrogance or pride,
which apparently elevates that body to the level of a "cult," a term
typically applied to identify and distinguish Christian churches from
non-Christian churches.
At first glance
this view seems quite plausible. There are a number of conservative Reformed
and Presbyterian denominations in North America alone, and each one contains
sincere and committed Christians. Many also contain ministers who are notable
for their public and articulate opposition to various doctrinal errors, and the
PRC and the related ministry, Still Waters Revival Books (SWRB), rejoice in the
truth of these particular testimonies (SWRB's catalogue, http://www.swrb.com, even contains books
and cassettes by men outside the PRC promoting these points). But it is
important to note that by maintaining separate ecclesiastical constitutions,
organizations, and church courts, these distinct denominations are logically
and necessarily testifying to all others that they are the most faithful. It
is this inescapable claim to faithfulness that provides a reasonable justification
for their separate ecclesiastical existence. If each denomination
really considered the others to be equally faithful as itself, then they would
all be united together in obedience to Christ's command (John 17:21,22). It is
only a need to defend distinctive doctrines or practices that can Scripturally
justify a church remaining separate from other churches. By its very existence,
a denomination is making a claim to being "the most faithful" of all
denominations, defending doctrines and practices that the others are not
adequately defending or promoting. If a denomination maintains a separate
existence when it could have merely joined together with another denomination
of acceptable principles and practices, would that not be a schismatic organization,
unscripturally separated from other members of Christ's body?
Think about it
this way: If someone were to ask you, "Is your church the most faithful
Reformed or Presbyterian church that you know of?" and you responded,
"no," the obvious next question would be, "Then what are you
doing there?!!"
Shouldn't it be the goal of every Christian to be a part of the purest and most
faithful church he or she knows about (Phil. 3:16)? If not, then Christians
will consciously be supporting error and unfaithfulness by their membership in,
and financial gifts to, a less faithful church (i.e., a church with sinful
teachings and practices). How can that be Scripturally justified? Clearly it
can't be. Thus by your membership in a particular church, you are
implicitly claiming that your church is the most faithful church. Otherwise you wouldn't
be there, you would go to the one you considered to be more faithful --
assuming you were willing to follow the Biblical command to separate from
erring brethren (Rom. 16:17).
This makes
it plain that the Puritan Reformed Church's claim to be the most faithful
church at present is no different from what other churches are claiming: all
churches are making this claim by their very existence, if not openly and
explicitly, then covertly and implicitly. If the Reformed Presbyterian Church of
North America (RPCNA), for example, considered the Presbyterian Church in
America (PCA) to be equally or even more faithful than itself, it would join
with the PCA. By the same token, if the PCA considered the RPCNA to be equally
or more faithful than itself, it would join with the RPCNA. Thus both of
these denominations are testifying against each other's unfaithfulness by
remaining separate from the other. The RPCNA is therefore claiming to be more
faithful than the PCA (and all other denominations it hasn't united with) and
the PCA is claiming to be more faithful than the RPCNA (and all other
denominations it hasn't united with). Is this arrogance and pride? If so, these
denominations should repent and merge together. Separate denominational
existences can only be Scripturally justified by the need to defend necessary
doctrinal distinctives, and this does not make a church a cult. Each denomination is
making an exclusive claim to being the most faithful of all (at least within a
particular nation) or else it must consider itself to be unjustly separated
from brethren contrary to Christ's command. This exclusive claim is an
inescapable concept.
Sadly, it seems to have escaped the detractors of the PRC.
Like all other
churches, the Puritan Reformed Church claims itself to be the most faithful.
People who criticize this claim are either being hypocritical or schismatic. Hypocritical, because
their church also claims to be most faithful, at least implicitly by its
separate existence. Or schismatic, because if their church is not more faithful
than the others, then it should repent of its unfaithfulness and unite with the
church that is more faithful. Take your pick.
Are the
Covenanters a cult, because in order to justify their necessary and separate
existence they explicitly claim to be most faithful to the real scriptural
attainments of the First and Second Reformations? If that is our
detractors' current definition of a cult, then the best place for them to stand
is in front of a mirror. When members of the other denominations become
conscious of the image of their own self-contradiction and self-condemnation,
then this false charge against the PRC, like the many others that have preceded
it, will be exposed for what it truly is -- vanity and misrepresentation.
********
Resources Related to
Wagner's
"Are the Covenanters a
Cult?"
Resources #2, #4, #7, #10, #14
and #15 are all first time email sale listings!
********
Resource 1.
ANDERSON, JOHN
Overcoming Division and
Unifying the Visible Church (1794)
A sermon (of 24
pages) on "Cease, my son, to hear the instruction that causeth to err from
the words of knowledge" (Prov. 19:27). The author writes,
What
is aimed at in this discourse is, to strike at a principal root of the numerous
divisions now in the visible church. It teaches that we ought not to be in a
state of separation from any church-communion, but upon such grounds as are
scriptural; and upon such considerations, as involving the declarative glory of
God, are of inconceivable and infinite importance. Were
this doctrine embraced, there would be no separate church-communions upon
trivial pretences; or for the sake of religious tenets or usages in the worship
of God which have no foundation in his word; no separate church-communions on
account of local customs, uncertain opinions, or uninstituted ceremonies; no
separate church-communions founded on the narrow and interested views of a
faction. What is here attempted is a seasonable application of the
cautions, with which the scriptures abound, against false teachers. To direct
church-members to the right use and application of such cautions will be the
endeavor of the faithful ministers of Christ; an endeavor which is rendered
peculiarly necessary by the corruptions which prevail in the present (divided--RB)
state of the visible church. Those who reckon that
practical religion is not concerned in the subject of this discourse should
consider that true believers have it for their distinguishing character, that
they abhor false doctrine, and avoid communion with the teachers of it (John
10:5, Rev. 14:4).
(Bound photocopy) $9.95-80%=$1.99 (US funds)
(Hardcover photocopy) $15.00 (US
funds)
(Cassette) $9.95-60%=$3.98 (US funds)
********
FIRST TIME EMAIL SALE
LISTING!